Fort Myers vs. Fort Lauderdale: Which City is Right for You? Comparing Real Estate, Cost of Living, Culture, and More

fort myers houses waterfront and beach access apartments

If you’re thinking about moving to Florida, you might be deciding between a house in Fort Myers or home in Fort Lauderdale. Both cities offer beautiful weather and access to the coast, but their real estate markets and lifestyles differ greatly. Fort Myers is known for its relaxed, small-town feel and affordable housing, while Fort Lauderdale brings a more urban atmosphere with a higher price tag.

From home prices to community, each city has unique aspects to consider. Let’s break down the key differences in this Redfin article to help you find which Florida city is perfect for your next move.

view of beach off fishing pier fort myers

Housing in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

When it comes to housing, Fort Myers and Fort Lauderdale offer distinct lifestyles and price points. 

Housing in Fort Myers

Fort Myers offers a more relaxed real estate market with a range of options, from suburban single-family homes to waterfront properties. This city is ideal for homebuyers seeking more space, with many Fort Myers neighborhoods and suburbs featuring larger lots, yards, and driveways. Whether you’re looking for a friendly community or a quiet spot for retirement, Fort Myers provides affordable real estate compared to larger Florida cities.

fort myers houses waterfront and beach access apartments

Housing in Fort Lauderdale

Fort Lauderdale’s real estate market is known for its diversity and urban living. From luxury high-rise condos overlooking the Intracoastal Waterway to charming mid-century homes in trendy Fort Lauderdale neighborhoods like Victoria Park, Fort Lauderdale caters to buyers looking for upscale coastal living. The city’s layout is more urban, with many properties near downtown or the beach featuring private docks and outdoor spaces, ideal for those embracing the boating lifestyle.

fort lauderdale houses

Cost of living in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Overall, the cost of living in Fort Myers is about 12% lower than in Fort Lauderdale, making it a more affordable option for those seeking coastal living. Differences in housing, utilities, groceries, and healthcare can impact daily expenses between these two cities.

1. Utilities

Utilities in Fort Myers are about 1% lower than in Fort Lauderdale. The smaller size and less urbanized nature of Fort Myers help keep energy consumption down, while Fort Lauderdale’s larger population and more developed infrastructure, particularly the demand for air conditioning during hot summers, result in slightly higher utility costs.

2. Groceries

Groceries are around 5% more expensive in Fort Lauderdale than in Fort Myers. Proximity to Miami’s larger metro area drives up demand and transportation costs in Fort Lauderdale, while Fort Myers benefits from local agricultural areas, leading to more stable grocery prices.

3. Transportation

Transportation costs in Fort Myers are 6% higher. The city’s smaller size and less traffic result in shorter commutes and lower fuel usage, while Fort Lauderdale’s more urban layout and greater reliance on cars increase gas and vehicle maintenance expenses.

4. Healthcare

Healthcare costs in Fort Myers are 19% higher than in Fort Lauderdale. Although both cities have quality medical facilities, Fort Myers’ healthcare is more expensive due to a smaller network of specialized services compared to Fort Lauderdale’s extensive options.

5. Lifestyle

Lifestyle expenses in Fort Myers are about 2% lower than in Fort Lauderdale. Fort Myers’ relaxed, laid-back environment means fewer high-cost recreational activities, whereas Fort Lauderdale’s lively social scene, including upscale dining and nightlife, contributes to higher lifestyle costs.

port and ocean in fort myers west florida

Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale in size and population

Fort Myers and Fort Lauderdale both offer coastal living, but the scale and density of these cities are quite different. Fort Myers covers about 49 square miles, creating a more open, laid-back environment with plenty of space to breathe. In contrast, Fort Lauderdale’s 36 square miles are more densely developed, blending urban and suburban areas. While Fort Lauderdale’s population exceeds 180,000, Fort Myers has a smaller population of around 86,000. This lower population density in Fort Myers contributes to its relaxed atmosphere, while Fort Lauderdale’s higher density fosters a more energetic, fast-paced lifestyle along its bustling waterfronts.

Weather and climate in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Fort Myers’ climate and Fort Lauderdale’s climate share a similar subtropical weather, characterized by warm, humid summers and mild, comfortable winters. Both cities experience abundant sunshine, making them ideal for outdoor activities year-round. The primary weather difference comes down to slightly warmer and drier conditions in Fort Myers compared to Fort Lauderdale’s higher humidity. Both cities are vulnerable to hurricanes during the Atlantic hurricane season, typically from June through November, making storm preparedness a priority for residents.

fort lauderdale condos

The job market in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Fort Myers: Tourism and healthcare hub

Fort Myers’ economy is heavily driven by tourism, healthcare, and retail. The city’s growing population has spurred the expansion of healthcare services, with institutions like Lee Health being major employers in the area. The tourism industry thrives year-round, thanks to the city’s proximity to popular vacation spots like Sanibel Island and Fort Myers Beach. With an employment rate of around 58%, Fort Myers offers steady job opportunities, particularly in hospitality, healthcare, and retail sectors. The median household income is $63,000.

Fort Lauderdale: Booming tourism and corporate growth

Fort Lauderdale boasts a diverse economy led by tourism, finance, and marine industries. The city is a major yachting hub, attracting global visitors, while its growing corporate sector includes businesses in finance, real estate, and tech. With an employment rate of 61.4% and a median household income of $81,000, Fort Lauderdale provides a wider range of higher-paying jobs. The city is also seeing growth in the healthcare industry, with institutions like Broward Health serving as key employers.

first street fort myers fl

Transportation in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Fort Myers: Car-centric with limited public transit

Transportation in Fort Myers is primarily car-dependent, with limited public transit options and relatively low walkability. Most residents rely on personal vehicles for commuting and errands, with major routes like I-75 and US-41 serving the city. Traffic congestion is generally mild compared to larger cities, but commuting by car remains the most common method of transportation. Public transit is available through LeeTran buses, but service is limited and less frequently used by residents.

Fort Lauderdale: Car-dependent with better transit options

Fort Lauderdale also leans heavily on car use, though it offers more public transportation options than Fort Myers. The city has a growing public transit network, including Broward County Transit (BCT) buses and the Sun Trolley, making it more accessible without a car. The Brightline high-speed rail service connects Fort Lauderdale to Miami and West Palm Beach, providing a convenient option for commuters. While driving remains dominant, walkable neighborhoods near the beach and downtown areas, as well as bike-sharing programs, are increasing in popularity.

fort lauderdale florida beach life

Travel in and out of Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Both Fort Myers and Fort Lauderdale are served by major airports, but Fort Lauderdale provides a wider range of public transportation options, including high-speed rail and cruise access, while Fort Myers is more reliant on car and air travel.

  • Fort Myers: Southwest Florida International Airport, Amtrak nearby, Greyhound bus service, and access to cruises from Port Tampa.
  • Fort Lauderdale: Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport, Brightline and Amtrak trains, Greyhound and Megabus, plus Port Everglades for cruises.

fort myers pier and beach

Lifestyle and things to do in Fort Myers and Fort Lauderdale

A day in the life of a Fort Myers local

Living in Fort Myers means embracing a laid-back lifestyle filled with natural beauty and a touch of history. The day often starts with a sunrise walk on the beach or a bike ride through the lush trails of Caloosahatchee Regional Park. As the day progresses, locals might enjoy fishing off the Sanibel Causeway, kayaking through Lovers Key State Park, or exploring nearby islands like Sanibel and Captiva. Evenings are perfect for taking in local art at the downtown River District or catching a show at the Barbara B. Mann Performing Arts Hall.

Top things to do in Fort Myers

Google Street View of Downtown River District

Fort Myers parks and green gems

  • Kayak through the mangroves at Lovers Key State Park.
  • Fish at the Sanibel Causeway for scenic coastal views.
  • Bike the trails of Caloosahatchee Regional Park.
  • Dolphin-watch on a cruise in Estero Bay.
  • Birdwatch at Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve.

Google Street View of Lovers Key State Park

Fort Myers tourist attractions

  • Edison and Ford Winter Estates
  • Lakes Park
  • Manatee Park
  • Fort Myers Beach
  • Sanibel Lighthouse

A day in the life of a Fort Lauderdale local

Fort Lauderdale locals enjoy a mix of luxury and leisure, making the most of the city’s waterfront lifestyle and cultural scene. Mornings might start with a paddleboarding session at Hugh Taylor Birch State Park or a stroll along the scenic Fort Lauderdale Beach Promenade. As the day goes on, residents often relax at upscale restaurants on Las Olas Boulevard or take a yacht tour through the city’s intricate canals. Evenings bring lively nightlife with music, art galleries, and fine dining experiences, perfect for embracing the city’s energetic vibe. 

Top things to do in Fort Lauderdale

Google Street View of the Las Olas Boulevard

Fort Lauderdale parks and green gems

  • Yacht tours through the city’s waterways
  • Snorkel or dive at nearby coral reefs
  • Paddleboard at Hugh Taylor Birch State Park
  • Walk the Fort Lauderdale Beach Promenade
  • Cycle along the scenic Riverwalk.

Google Street View of the Riverwalk

Fort Lauderdale tourist attractions

Food and culture in Fort Lauderdale vs Fort Myers

Fort Lauderdale: The Venice of America 

Fort Lauderdale, often called the “Venice of America,” is a vibrant coastal city where the food scene revolves around fresh seafood, Latin-American influences, and a laid-back atmosphere. Dockside dining is popular, with many restaurants offering fresh catches of the day. Whether indulging in stone crab at 15th Street Fisheries or enjoying tacos at the local hotspot El Camino, Fort Lauderdale blends coastal flavors with casual elegance. The city comes alive during events like the Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show and the Las Olas Wine and Food Festival, where locals celebrate the arts, yachting culture, and international cuisine.

Fort Myers: The City of Palms 

Meanwhile, Fort Myers, known as the “City of Palms,” embraces a more relaxed, Southern charm. The food here is a reflection of the city’s history and proximity to the Gulf, with everything from authentic Southern BBQ to fresh-caught seafood dominating the menus. Downtown Fort Myers hosts the River District’s art walks and outdoor markets, where residents can enjoy farm-to-table fare and local treats like grouper sandwiches and key lime pie. Festivals such as the Edison Festival of Light honor the city’s heritage, while seafood festivals bring the community together for local dishes and live music in an atmosphere reminiscent of old Florida.

canal in fort lauderdale florida

The Sports scene in Fort Myers vs Fort Lauderdale

Fort Myers: The Spring training hub

Fort Myers is best known for its role in Major League Baseball’s Spring Training, hosting two iconic teams each year: the Boston Red Sox and the Minnesota Twins. While it lacks major league teams during the regular season, Spring Training brings a strong sports culture to the area. The city is also home to the Florida Everblades, a minor league hockey team in the ECHL.

Fort Lauderdale: Soccer and water sports paradise

In contrast, Fort Lauderdale’s sports scene centers around its vibrant soccer culture, with Inter Miami CF playing home games here. Additionally, the city’s coastal location makes water sports and yachting an integral part of life. Though Fort Lauderdale doesn’t host an NFL or MLB team directly, nearby Miami is home to the Miami Dolphins, and the area has a historic connection to baseball through Spring Training.

The post Fort Myers vs. Fort Lauderdale: Which City is Right for You? Comparing Real Estate, Cost of Living, Culture, and More appeared first on Redfin | Real Estate Tips for Home Buying, Selling & More.

Posted in:

Post Tags: